Friday, 23 March 2012

Health department abortion approach is contradicted by Andrew Lansley's announcement

In a press statement issued today by Paul Tully, SPUC's general secretary, the Society accuses the department of health of organizing a whitewash of abortion practice under the 1967 Abortion Act.

Paul Tully says that Andrew Lansley's statement that abortion clinics would be subject to "unannounced inspections" is  "clearly an exercise by the department of health to sanitise its abortion partners following scandals such as the 'wrong sex' abortions, where the Telegraph found evidence of doctors lying about the grounds for abortion."

Paul Tully says that the Department of Health is promoting abortion on demand - and that the department is prompting doctors to lie when certifying women for abortions.

Consider the following ... Andrew Lansley, the health Secretary, (pictured above), is today reported as saying:
"The rules in the Abortion Act are there for a reason - to ensure there are safeguards for women before an abortion can be carried out. Abortion shouldn't be undertaken lightly and the right checks and balances must be in place."
By way of contrast, the Department of Health website, on a page entitled "Abortion: where to go", responds to the question "Can I be refused an abortion" as follows:
"It's rare for anyone to be refused an abortion. A doctor may have moral objections to abortion, but if that’s the case they should refer you to another doctor who can help. It can be very difficult to get later abortions, so the earlier you seek help the better.

"By law, two doctors have to agree that you can have an abortion. Usually this is the first doctor you see and a second doctor who will perform the abortion, or one who works at the community contraceptive clinic or hospital."
Also sharply contrasting with Andrew Lansley's reported comments today is the following policy statement published by the Department of Health in January 2010:
"The decision to terminate a pregnancy rests with the woman and her doctors. If an abortion is requested by a young woman (under 16 years of age), doctors have an obligation to encourage the young woman to involve her parents or guardian, but generally they should not override the patient’s views." (Section 140, Equality Impact Assessment for National Sexual Health Policy)
Finally, the contradiction in the government position can be seen in the tragic fact that only last October, the British government renewed its commitment to a partnership programme with the International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF) worth over £43 million (of our money as taxpayers). Amongst IPPF's aims is to have abortion recognized as a universal human right.

How Andrew Lansley, the Secretary of State for Health, acts on these breaches of the Abortion Act by British abortion clinics will be the real test of his strong expressions of concern on this matter.

I urge UK readers to contact their MP and to ask him or her to challenge Andrew Lansley on department of health policy in these areas.

Comments on this blog? Email them to
Sign up for alerts to new blog-posts and/or for SPUC's other email services
Follow SPUC on Twitter
Like SPUC's Facebook Page
Please support SPUC. Please donate, join, and/or leave a legacy

Thursday, 22 March 2012

African mothers want healthcare not abortion, international conference hears

Mothers in Africa want maternal healthcare, not abortion, an international conference in central London has heard.

The "Abortion or maternal health? What should the UK be funding in developing countries?" conference, held by SPUC on Tuesday, heard from an international line-up of experts in maternal healthcare, law and research. The conference was attended by medical professionals, bioethicists, students and religious representatives from many countries.

Prof. Robert Walley
Professor Robert Walley, a leading obstetrician and founder of MaterCare International, told the conference that: "In the countries in which I work, one in seven mothers will die due to lack of medical equipment...It is ridiculous to supply women with abortion and condoms when they need access to emergency obstetrical care...Abortion is a sin of commission, but failing to provide mothers with obstetrical care is a sin of omission", he said. "We are here to uphold women's dignity".

Professor Walley described obstetrics as the most privileged of professions. The advent of mass abortion and contraception in the 1970s led to obstetricians who wouldn't support abortion being forced out of the profession. "Because I was against abortion, I was told to change speciality or leave", said Professor Walley. "Medics must live according to their consciences, which tells them not to perform abortions. Medics are trained to save life not destroy it." Professor Walley said tha people in the developing world are getting angry at Western pro-abortion bullying. "The West has destroyed marriage and the family and is now imposing its decadence on the conservative developing world", he said.

MaterCare International's Charter of Maternal Rights secures both maternal health and the welcome gift of children. Since 2005 MaterCare International has run a cutting-edge maternal health project in Kenya, bringing healthcare and hope to rural mothers. MaterCare International also organises workshops with multi-disciplinary speakers to educate medics in ethics. The late Pope John Paul II gave direct support and inspiration to MaterCare International and Catholic obstetricians everywhere. Professor Walley added that most Catholic priests are faithful to the pro-life cause but need support.

Dr Roger Kiska
Dr Roger Kiska, from Vienna, senior legal counsel of the Alliance Defense Fund (ADF), told the conference that no obligation exists on states to legalise abortion in international law. Not a single United Nations (UN) treaty mentions abortion, let alone a right to abortion. No party to an international treaty would have intended abortion when signing a treaty, he said. Also, there is no norm regarding abortion in customary international law. Any trend in national laws to allow abortion does not create any obligation to allow abortion, Dr Kiska said.

Many articles of international conventions actually protect the right to life of unborn children. For example, it is illegal under international law to execute pregnant women. A European Court of Justice judgment on patent law held that human life begins at conception, said Dr Kiska. There is an international consensus that abortion is not a freedom but something that should be reduced.

John Smeaton
However, international conventions and treaties are being re-interpreted via manipulation of officials by pro-abortion lobbyists, said Dr Kiska. Although the European Union (EU) has no competency over abortion, non-binding resolutions by the European Parliament and by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe assert that European states should allow abortion on demand.

Dr Kiska concluded his address by saying: "I'm very proud to work with SPUC" and praising SPUC's work defending the right to life in international law. John Smeaton, SPUC director, said that the Holy See is deeply appreciative of SPUC's support by way of pro-life lobbying at the United Nations (UN).

Terry Brown
Conference delegates networked over lunch and afterwards shared information on SPUC's resources, initiatives and partners. Terry Brown of the Society of St Vincent de Paul (SVP) told the conference how the SVP works to support poor women in Sudan and globally. Being pro-life and being pro-woman automatically go together. Mr Brown asked delegates to pray for the work of both the SVP and SPUC.

Dr Obielumani Ideh, obstetrician and researcher from Nigeria, shared heartbreaking stories of the massive gap in healthcare between the UK and Africa. Women in Nigeria are forced to give birth in appalling conditions. Medical and cultural factors male Nigerian women very wary of surgery such as caesarean section delivery.

Dr Obi Ideh (2nd from left)
In Nigeria, illegal abortions are being done under the euphemism of 'post-abortion care', said Dr Ideh. Abortion groups are selling manual vacuum aspirators (MVAs) which are being used to perform illegal abortions. Massive government funding of the abortion group IPAS in Nigeria adds to a dramatic shortfall in real healthcare. Dr Ideh said that the problem of maternal mortality arises mainly because governments fail to provide the appropriate resources and infrastructure.

The international 'Safe Motherhood Initiative' soon turned into the abortion lobbying group 'Women Deliver', said Dr Ideh. Professor Walley told the conference that 'Women Deliver' have made a policy decision not to use word 'mother'. Dr Ideh said that community-based midwifery needs to be spread in the developing world, and that pro-lifers are called to share the pro-life message within their own families, schools and local communities.

Youth enjoying the conference
Fiorella Nash MA (Cantab.), a mother of three children and a researcher on maternal mortality for SPUC, said that high maternal mortality in the developing world is a scandal. Better healthcare not abortion is the solution. Access to abortion is being funded and promoted at the expense of urgent women's healthcare needs, said Mrs Nash. Sadly, even Britain's CAFOD (Catholic Agency For Overseas Development) had reacted angrily when SPUC pointed out how the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) would be used to further the abortion agenda.

Pro-abortion groups often inflate or fabricate illegal abortion figures in developing countries. Studies claiming high illegal abortion rates often lump together induced and spontaneous abortion, and confuse 'safe' with 'legal' abortion. Mrs Nash said that government and parliamentary reports are also often skewed by an obsession with promoting abortion. Also, Britain's Department for International Development (DFID) has failed to provide detailed figures on how it's bankrolling abortion overseas.
Eve Farren

There is a massive gap between poor rural women dying in huts in the developing world and the pro-abortion elite in carpeted boardrooms of world capitals. The real reason for world poverty is corrupt leaders, not a lack of birth control, concluded Mrs Nash.

There was a range of excellent questions and contributions from delegates. Eve Farren of Bristol Students for Life said there was a big rise in pro-life student activism in the UK.

Robin Haig, SPUC's chairman, concluded the conference by calling on delegates to help restore the dignity of motherhood and ensure that every childbirth is a joyful occasion.
Robin Haig

An album of photographs from the conference can be viewed at

SPUC has produced an in-depth briefing on maternal mortality.

Comments on this blog? Email them to
Sign up for alerts to new blog-posts and/or for SPUC's other email services
Follow SPUC on Twitter
Like SPUC's Facebook Page
Please support SPUC. Please donate, join, and/or leave a legacy

Monday, 19 March 2012

Must-read pro-life news-stories, Mon 19 Mar

Top story:

UK government launches consultation on same-sex marriage
The British government has launched its consultation document on gay marriage (see SPUC's position paper, background paper and official policy on gay marriage). The consultation is an attempt to achieve a fait accompli on the enactment of gay marriage. The consultation document says: "[T]his consultation is about how we best remove the ban on same-sex couples having a civil marriage, not on whether this should or should not happen." John Smeaton, SPUC director, commented: "We must re-double of our resistance to the government's plans before it's too late." [John Smeaton, 15 March]

Other stories:

  • Bioethicists propose child-per-family quota based on volume and weight [BioEdge, 17 March]
Sexual ethics
Comments on this blog? Email them to
Sign up for alerts to new blog-posts and/or for SPUC's other email services
Follow SPUC on Twitter
Like SPUC's Facebook Page
Please support SPUC. Please donate, join, and/or leave a legacy

Please support Bishop Alan Hopes, under attack from abortionists

The Good Counsel Network reports that the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS), one of the UK's largest abortion providers, is attacking Bishop Alan Hopes of Westminster for his support of the 40 Days For Life London vigils. Bishop Hopes is due to attend the vigil outside the BPAS centre in central London on 30 March. Please:
  • show your support for Bishop Hopes by attending the vigil on Friday 30 March, 7pm to 8.30pm, north-west corner of Bedford Square, London WC1B 3HP
  • pray for Bishop Hopes and all those involved in 40 Days For Life
  • pray for all those who work at BPAS, that God will turn their hearts away from death to life
  • pray for all those women who visit BPAS, that God will strengthen them to protect their unborn children.
Comments on this blog? Email them to
Sign up for alerts to new blog-posts and/or for SPUC's other email services
Follow SPUC on Twitter
Like SPUC's Facebook Page
Please support SPUC. Please donate, join, and/or leave a legacy